August 29th, 2021

7:10 runtime

Handguns come in all sizes and even a variety of shapes.

There are many reasons for this, such as concealability, ergonomic preferences and primary uses.

But I think most of us appreciate the many models approach as well I know I do.

XD-M Elite 5.25" vs XD-M Elite 3.8"

Is one more accurate?

How about recoil management?

Capacity differences… etc.

Man dual wielding XD-M Elite pistols

So, when I can, I like to do a direct comparison a head-to-head if you will.

Lets start with the accuracy question because I think thats the most subjective.

If that is the case, what then is the point of testing or comparing?

A pair of XD-M Elite pistols

Ergonomics and small differences can be big factors in how well Im able to shoot the gun.

It can be as simple as how comfortable one of my fingers feels when gripping it.

The 3.8 Compact squishes them together pretty tightly, leaving the pinky feeling a bit left out.

Target measurements for the XD-M Elite comparison testing

Sometimes, just that different feel in the hand can make a difference in my accuracy with off-hand shooting.

In other words, on any given comparison I never know what is going to matter most.

The deciding factor turned out to be the HEX Dragonfly.

XD-M® Elite 5.25" Precision

Go to forum thread

XD-MElite 5.25" Precision

XD-MElite 3.8" Compact OSPTM w/ HEX Dragonfly

XD-M® Elite 3.8" Compact OSP™ w/ HEX Dragonfly

Facebook Share

Twitter Share

Pinterest Share

Article image

Article image